The molecular basis for diminished muscle function in acidosis: a proposal.

A testable molecular proposal for the effects of acidosis on skeletal and cardiac muscle is presented. It is based on fluorescence studies published in 1974, which provided evidence for carboxylates in an EF-hand Ca2+ binding site having an abnormal pKa. This results in an H+-bound Blocked substate in the 3-state model of muscle regulation whose contribution inhibits myosin binding in the pH 7 to 6 range. A schematic cartoon illustrates the substate within the 3-state model.

The mechanism of thin filament regulation: Models in conflict?

In a recent JGP article, Heeley et al. (2019. J. Gen. Physiol https://doi.org/10.1085/jgp.201812198) reopened the debate about two- versus three-state models of thin filament regulation. The authors review their work, which measures the rate constant of Pi release from myosin.ADP.Pi activated by actin or thin filaments under a variety of conditions. They conclude that their data can be described by a two-state model and raise doubts about the generally accepted three-state model as originally formulated by McKillop and Geeves (1993. Biophys. J. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0006-3495(93)81110-X). However, in the following article, we follow Plato's dictum that "twice and thrice over, as they say, good it is to repeat and review what is good." We have therefore reviewed the evidence for the three- and two-state models and present our view that the evidence is overwhelmingly in favor of three structural states of the thin filament, which regulate access of myosin to its binding sites on actin and, hence, muscle contractility.

The Relaxation Properties of Myofibrils Are Compromised by Amino Acids that Stabilize α-Tropomyosin.

We investigated the functional impact of α-tropomyosin (Tm) substituted with one (D137L) or two (D137L/G126R) stabilizing amino acid substitutions on the mechanical behavior of rabbit psoas skeletal myofibrils by replacing endogenous Tm and troponin (Tn) with recombinant Tm mutants and purified skeletal Tn. Force recordings from myofibrils (15°C) at saturating [Ca2+] showed that Tm-stabilizing substitutions did not significantly affect the maximal isometric tension and the rates of force activation (kACT) and redevelopment (kTR). However, a clear effect was observed on force relaxation: myofibrils with D137L/G126R or D137L Tm showed prolonged durations of the slow phase of relaxation and decreased rates of the fast phase. Both Tm-stabilizing substitutions strongly decreased the slack sarcomere length (SL) at submaximal activating [Ca2+] and increased the steepness of the SL-passive tension relation. These effects were reversed by addition of 10 mM 2,3-butanedione 2-monoxime. Myofibrils also showed an apparent increase in Ca2+ sensitivity. Measurements of myofibrillar ATPase activity in the absence of Ca2+ showed a significant increase in the presence of these Tms, indicating that single and double stabilizing substitutions compromise the full inhibition of contraction in the relaxed state. These data can be understood with the three-state (blocked-closed-open) theory of muscle regulation, according to which the mutations increase the contribution of the active open state in the absence of Ca2+ (M-). Force measurements on myofibrils substituted with C-terminal truncated TnI showed similar compromised relaxation effects, indicating the importance of TnI-Tm interactions in maintaining the blocked state. It appears that reducing the flexibility of native Tm coiled-coil structure decreases the optimum interactions of the central part of Tm with the C-terminal region of TnI. This results in a shift away from the blocked state, allowing myosin binding and activity in the absence of Ca2+. This work provides a basis for understanding the effects of disease-producing mutations in muscle proteins.

The myosin-activated thin filament regulatory state, M⁻-open: a link to hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM).

This review proposes a link between the hypertrophic (HCM) and restrictive cardiomyopathies caused by mutations in several sarcomeric thin filament proteins, and the open state of the three-state muscle regulation theory. The three characteristics of various muscle systems reconstituted from HCM mutated proteins (increased Ca(2+)-sensitivity, increased basal activity in the absence of Ca(2+), and decreased cooperativity) can be explained by the contribution of a myosin-induced open state (M (-) ), which elevates the basal activity and competes with the normal Ca(2+)-activated pathway. A model based on the three-state theory of regulation, shows how a change in the closed/blocked equilibrium caused by a mutation that weakens the binding of troponin I to tropomyosin-actin can produce the characteristics of HCM. This review also shows that in the M (-) state, Ca(2+) can shift the closed-open equilibrium of the N-terminal hydrophobic region of troponin C without affecting activity.

John Gergely (1919-2013): a pillar in the muscle protein field.

Dr. John Gergely passed away on July 26, 2013 after a long and distinguished career. His publications spanned 67 years. He founded the Department of Muscle Research in the Retina Foundation (which later became the Boston Biomedical Research Institute) and served as director for 34 years. Dr. Gergely served on the editorial boards of ten scientific journals. He was elected as a Fellow of both the Biophysical Society and the American Association for the Advancement of Science. Dr. Gergely made major contributions concerning muscle protein structure and function. He was best known for his work on the troponin complex. The insights of John and his associates have provided the foundation for our understanding of calcium regulation in skeletal and cardiac muscle.

Polymorphism in tropomyosin structure and function.

Tropomyosins (Tm) in humans are expressed from four distinct genes and by alternate splicing >40 different Tm polypeptide chains can be made. The functional Tm unit is a dimer of two parallel polypeptide chains and these can be assembled from identical (homodimer) or different (heterodimer) polypeptide chains provided both chains are of the same length. Since most cells express multiple isoforms of Tm, the number of different homo and heterodimers that can be assembled becomes very large. We review the mechanism of dimer assembly and how preferential assembly of some heterodimers is driven by thermodynamic stability. We examine how in vitro studies can reveal functional differences between Tm homo and heterodimers (stability, actin affinity, flexibility) and the implication for how there could be selection of Tm isomers in the assembly on to an actin filament. The role of Tm heterodimers becomes more complex when mutations in Tm are considered, such as those associated with cardiomyopathies, since mutations can appear in only one of the chains.

Long-range effects of familial hypertrophic cardiomyopathy mutations E180G and D175N on the properties of tropomyosin.

Cardiac α-tropomyosin (Tm) single-site mutations D175N and E180G cause familial hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (FHC). Previous studies have shown that these mutations increase both Ca(2+) sensitivity and residual contractile activity at low Ca(2+) concentrations, which causes incomplete relaxation during diastole resulting in hypertrophy and sarcomeric disarray. However, the molecular basis for the cause and the difference in the severity of the manifested phenotypes of disease are not known. In this work we have (1) used ATPase studies using reconstituted thin filaments in solution to show that these FHC mutants result in an increase in Ca(2+) sensitivity and an increased residual level of ATPase, (2) shown that both FHC mutants increase the rate of cleavage at R133, ~45 residues N-terminal to the mutations, when free and bound to actin, (3) shown that for Tm-E180G, the increase in the rate of cleavage is greater than that for D175N, and (4) shown that for E180G, cleavage also occurs at a new site 53 residues C-terminal to E180G, in parallel with cleavage at R133. The long-range decreases in dynamic stability due to these two single-site mutations suggest increases in flexibility that may weaken the ability of Tm to inhibit activity at low Ca(2+) concentrations for D175N and to a greater degree for E180G, which may contribute to differences in the severity of FHC.

The 3-state model of muscle regulation revisited: is a fourth state involved?

The 3-state model of muscle regulation has been useful in explaining the roles of Ca2+ and myosin heads in activation and relaxation of striated muscle contraction. However, there are some phenomena, which cannot simply be explained by the 3-state model. These include increased Ca2+-binding caused by strong-binding myosin heads and residual active force at low Ca2+ in the case of familial hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. Here, I review experimental data which provide evidence for an additional state, a myosin-induced Open state present in the absence of Ca2+ (Open-Ca2+) which like the normal Open+Ca2+ state, is an active state and can allow myosin heads to cycle and generate force. A schematic diagram is presented which shows that the formation of the Open-Ca2+ state is on a parallel path with the formation of the Open+Ca2+ state and can contribute to activation.

Tropomyosin is in a reduced state in rabbit psoas muscle.

Tropomyosin (Tm) purified from skeletal and cardiac muscle often contains disulfide bonds due to oxidation of cysteine groups that are in close proximity in the coiled-coil structure. Are these disulfide crosslinks present in the muscle or produced by oxidation during preparation? To answer this question we reacted one part of freshly dissected rabbit psoas muscle fibers, which was permeabilized with Triton X-100, with N-ethyl maleimide (NEM) to block cysteine groups and another part with 5,5'-dithiobis(2-nitro benzoate) (DTNB) to facilitate disulfide bond formation by interchain sulfhydryl-disulfide exchange. We found, by high resolution gradient SDS polyacrylamide gels, that the NEM-treated muscle was only composed of uncrosslinked Tm and the DTNB treated muscle was composed of disulfide-crosslinked Tm. This work indicates that Tm exists in a reduced state in rabbit psoas muscle.

Ca2+-dependent photocrosslinking of tropomyosin residue 146 to residues 157-163 in the C-terminal domain of troponin I in reconstituted skeletal muscle thin filaments.

The Ca(2+)-dependent interaction of troponin I (TnI) with actin.tropomyosin (Tm) in muscle thin filaments is a critical step in the regulation of muscle contraction. Previous studies have suggested that, in the absence of Ca(2+), TnI interacts with Tm and actin in reconstituted muscle thin filaments, maintaining Tm at the outer domain of actin and blocking myosin-actin interaction. To obtain direct evidence for this Tm-TnI interaction, we performed photochemical crosslinking studies using Tm labeled with 4-maleimidobenzophenone at position 146 or 174 (Tm*146 or Tm*174, respectively), reconstituted with actin and troponin [composed of TnI, troponin T (TnT), and troponin C] or with actin and TnI. After near-UV irradiation, SDS gels of the Tm*146-containing thin filament showed three new high-molecular-weight bands determined to be crosslinked products Tm*146-TnI, Tm*146-troponin C, and Tm*146-TnT using fluorescence-labeled TnI, mass spectrometry, and Western blot analysis. While Tm*146-TnI was produced only in the absence of Ca(2+), the production of other crosslinked species did not show Ca(2+) dependence. Tm*174 mainly crosslinked to TnT. In the absence of actin, a similar crosslinking pattern was obtained with a much lower yield. A tryptic peptide from Tm*146-TnI with a molecular mass of 2601.2 Da that was not present in the tryptic peptides of Tm*146 or TnI was identified using HPLC and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight. This was shown, using absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy, to be the 4-maleimidobenzophenone-labeled peptide from Tm crosslinked to TnI peptide 157-163. These data, which show that a region in the C-terminal domain of TnI interacts with Tm in the absence of Ca(2+), support the hypothesis that a TnI-Tm interaction maintains Tm at the outer domain of actin and will help efforts to localize troponin in actin.Tm muscle thin filaments.

Conserved Asp-137 imparts flexibility to tropomyosin and affects function.

Tropomyosin (Tm) is an alpha-helical coiled-coil that controls muscle contraction by sterically regulating the myosin-actin interaction. Tm moves between three states on F-actin as either a uniform or a non-uniform semi-flexible rod. Tm is stabilized by hydrophobic residues in the "a" and "d" positions of the heptad repeat. The highly conserved Asp-137 is unusual in that it introduces a negative charge on each chain in a position typically occupied by hydrophobic residues. The occurrence of two charged residues in the hydrophobic region is expected to destabilize the region and impart flexibility. To determine whether this region is unstable, we have substituted hydrophobic Leu for Asp-137 and studied changes in Tm susceptibility to limited proteolysis by trypsin and changes in regulation. We found that native and Tm controls that contain Asp-137 were readily cleaved at Arg-133 with t 1/2 of 5 min. In contrast, the Leu-137 mutant was not cleaved under the same conditions. Actin stabilized Tm, causing a 10-fold reduction in the rate of cleavage at Arg-133. The actin-myosin subfragment S1 ATPase activity was greater for the Leu mutant compared with controls in the absence of troponin and in the presence of troponin and Ca2+. We conclude that the highly conserved Asp-137 destabilizes the middle of Tm, resulting in a more flexible region that is important for the cooperative activation of the thin filament by myosin. We thus have shown a link between the dynamic properties of Tm and its function.

Role of the head-to-tail overlap region in smooth and skeletal muscle beta-tropomyosin.

Tropomyosin (Tm) is an alpha-helical, parallel, two-chain coiled coil which binds along the length of actin filaments in both muscle and non-muscle cells. Smooth and skeletal muscle Tms differ extensively at the C-terminus encoded by exon 9. Replacement of the striated muscle specific exon 9a-encoded C-terminus with that encoded by exon 9d expressed in smooth muscle and non-muscle cells increases the affinity of unacetylated alpha-SkTm for actin [Cho, Y. J., and Hitchcock-Degregori, S. E. (1991) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 88, 10153-10157]. Here we show that swapping 10 amino acids at the C-terminus of beta-SkTm with the corresponding 10 amino acids of beta-SmTm had little effect on the regulation of S1 binding to actin, but Tm viscosity, Tm binding to actin, and troponin T1 binding to Tm all become like smooth rather than SkTm. beta-SkTm point mutations show that these properties are largely defined by the amino acids at two positions, 277 and 279. The N279L mutation reduces the viscosity of beta-SkTm to close to beta-SmTm values, while both residues contribute to the binding of TnT1. We also show that removing the first 11 N-terminal amino acids of beta-SmTm to make the mutant DeltaN-betaSmTm results in a 10-fold weakening in actin affinity compared to that of beta-SmTm. CD studies show no difference in thermal unfolding between beta-SmTm and DeltaN-betaSmTm; however, the viscosity of DeltaN-betaSmTm is much lower than that of the control. The results suggest that DeltaN-betaSmTm was unable to form filaments in solution but can form filaments on actin.

Functional homodimers and heterodimers of recombinant smooth muscle tropomyosin.

Skeletal and smooth muscle tropomyosin (Tm) require acetylation of their N-termini to bind strongly to actin. Tm containing an N-terminal alanine-serine (AS) extension to mimic acetylation has been widely used to increase binding. The current study investigates the ability of an N-terminal AS extension to mimic native acetylation for both alpha alpha and beta beta smooth Tm homodimers. We show that (1) AS alpha-Tm binds actin 100-fold tighter than alpha-Tm and 2-fold tighter than native smooth alphabeta-Tm, (2) beta-Tm requires an AS extension to bind actin, and (3) AS beta-Tm binds actin 10-fold weaker than AS alpha-Tm. Tm is present in smooth muscle tissues as >95% heterodimer; therefore, we studied the binding of recombinant alphabeta heterodimers with different AS extensions. This study shows that recombinant Tm requires an AS extension on both alpha and beta chains to bind like native Tm and that the alpha chain contributes more to actin binding than the beta chain. Once assembled onto an actin filament, all smooth muscle Tm's regulate S1 binding to actin Tm in the same way, irrespective of the presence of an AS extension.

Distances between tropomyosin sites across the muscle thin filament using luminescence resonance energy transfer: evidence for tropomyosin flexibility.

To obtain information about the interaction of tropomyosin (Tm) with actin associated with the regulatory states of the muscle thin filament, we used luminescence resonance energy transfer (LRET) between Tb(3+) as a donor and rhodamine as an acceptor. A novel Tb(3+) chelator, S-(2-nitro-5-thiobenzoate)cysteaminyl-DTPA-Cs124, was synthesized, which specifically labels Cys groups in proteins. With the Tb chelate as the donor and tetramethylrhodamine-5-maleimide as the acceptor, both bound to specific Cys groups of Tm, we obtained 67 A as the distance between Tm's across the actin filament, a much shorter value than that obtained from structural studies (72-86 A). The difference appears to be due to submillisecond motion associated with Tm flexibility, which brings the probes closer during the millisecond lifetime of the donor. Ca(2+) did not change the energy transfer with the reconstituted thin filament, but myosin subfragment 1 decreased the transfer, consistent with either a 5-6 A increase in distance or, more likely, a decrease in flexibility.

Myosin-induced movement of alphaalpha, alphabeta, and betabeta smooth muscle tropomyosin on actin observed by multisite FRET.

The interaction of the alphaalpha, betabeta, and alphabeta smooth muscle tropomyosin (Tm) isoforms with F-actin was systematically studied in the absence and in the presence of myosin subfragment 1 (S1) using multifrequency phase/modulation Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). A Gaussian double distance distribution model was adopted to fit FRET data between a 5-(2-iodoacetyl-amino-ethyl-amino)naphthalene-1-sulfonic acid donor at either Cys-36 of the beta-chain or Cys-190 of the alpha-chain and a 4-dimethylaminophenylazophenyl 4'-maleimide acceptor at Cys-374 of F-actin. Experimental data were obtained for singly and doubly labeled alphabeta Tm (donor only at alpha, only at beta, or both) and for doubly labeled alphaalpha or betabeta Tm. Data for singly labeled alphabetaTm were combined in a global analysis with doubly labeled alphabetaTm. In all doubly labeled isoforms, upon S1 binding, one donor-acceptor "apparent" distance increased slightly by 0.5-2 A, whereas the other decreased by 6-9 A. These changes are consistent with a uniform "rolling" motion of Tm over the F-actin surface. The analysis indicates that Tm occupies relatively well-defined positions, with some flexibility, in both the predominantly closed (-S1) and open (+S1) thin-filament states. The results for the alphabetaTm heterodimer indicate that the local twofold symmetry of alphaalpha or betabeta Tm is effectively broken in alphabetaTm bound to F-actin, which implies a difference between the alpha- and beta-chains in terms of their interaction with F-actin.

A modulatory role for the troponin T tail domain in thin filament regulation.

In striated muscle the force generating acto-myosin interaction is sterically regulated by the thin filament proteins tropomyosin and troponin (Tn), with the position of tropomyosin modulated by calcium binding to troponin. Troponin itself consists of three subunits, TnI, TnC, and TnT, widely characterized as being responsible for separate aspects of the regulatory process. TnI, the inhibitory unit is released from actin upon calcium binding to TnC, while TnT performs a structural role forming a globular head region with the regulatory TnI- TnC complex with a tail anchoring it within the thin filament. We have examined the properties of TnT and the TnT(1) tail fragment (residues 1-158) upon reconstituted actin-tropomyosin filaments. Their regulatory effects have been characterized in both myosin S1 ATPase and S1 kinetic and equilibrium binding experiments. We show that both inhibit the actin-tropomyosin-activated S1 ATPase with TnT(1) producing a greater inhibitory effect. The S1 binding data show that this inhibition is not caused by the formation of the blocked B-state but by significant stabilization of the closed C-state with a 10-fold reduction in the C- to M-state equilibrium, K(T), for TnT(1). This suggests TnT has a modulatory as well as structural role, providing an explanation for its large number of alternative isoforms.